
Leo Nelissen
Investing Group Leader
Summary
- Dividend growth streaks offer initial outperformance, but their alpha-generating power fades after five years, making streak length a poor primary investment filter.
- My biggest winners – Comfort Systems USA, GE Aerospace, and Antero Midstream – succeeded due to forward growth drivers, not dividend consistency.
- FIX and GE are rated Buy, with FIX benefiting from data center demand and GE from its aerospace dominance and turnaround. AM excels via buybacks and disciplined capital allocation.
- Dividend growth is valuable, but future fundamentals and strategic positioning outweigh historical payout streaks for long-term portfolio success.
- Looking for a helping hand in the market? Members of Main Street Alpha get exclusive ideas and guidance to navigate any climate. Learn More »

Introduction
I have to say that I woke up today feeling mildly provocative, as we’ll discuss a different angle on a very popular activity. That activity is dividend growth investing.
But before we do, let me ask you a question.
Do you screen your dividend stocks by how many years in a row they have raised the dividend?
If you do, you’re one of many.
And you have also been in a good spot lately, as the ratio between the ProShares S&P 500 Dividend Aristocrats ETF (NOBL) and the S&P 500 has made a comeback in recent weeks, mostly due to a rotation from growth stocks into value stocks (see below).

I get the appeal of companies that have hiked their dividends for at least 25 consecutive years (Dividend Aristocrats) or 50 consecutive years (Dividend Kings). You have also seen me bring up these numbers in articles, as it’s obviously a good thing when a company is able to consistently hike its dividend. I will never make the case that it’s a bad thing.
However, over the past 10 years (and before that), these companies have been outperformed by the market. And as the chart below shows, it wasn’t even a close race.

Now, bear in mind that I’m also a dividend growth investor. Almost every penny of my liquid net worth is in a portfolio that I call the dividend growth portfolio.
There are just two important things to keep in mind:
- I apply a different strategy than most.
- Some of my biggest winners aren’t typical dividend growth stocks at all.
In this article, I’ll show you two studies that explain how we should handle dividend streaks and walk you through some of my biggest winners and why I continue to believe in them.
So, as we have a lot on our plate today, let’s dive right in!
The Research Is Right (With A Twist)
I love data. And I would never disagree with a fact. However, we always need to take things with a grain of salt.
If you have read my articles for a while, you know that I believe in the power of dividend growth stocks. As we can see below, between 1973 and 2025, dividend growers and initiators have returned 10.2% per year with a standard deviation of roughly 16.0%.

Essentially, it means that these companies give us both outperforming returns and lower risk. How awesome is that? Where else can you get a higher return by taking less risk?
Just imagine what $10,000 invested in 1973 in that group of stocks would be worth now.
It’s $1.7 million (10,000*1.1022^53)
So far, so good. What matters here, however, is that this includes “initiators.” These are companies that just started paying a dividend. They have a dividend growth streak of zero years (or just a handful, depending on how strict we are with the definition).
It shifts the focus from duration to other factors.
Take Dividend Growth Streaks With A Grain Of Salt
A terrific dividend growth streak is a nice bonus. Being able to consistently raise a dividend is a great sign of strength. Realty Income (O), for example, has hiked its dividend for 32 consecutive years (and more as a private company before its IPO). Despite sell-offs during recessions, investors could count almost with certainty (there’s never a guarantee) on a hike.

However, let me say this. While a dividend growth streak is beneficial, don’t ever buy a stock for that reason alone. A long dividend growth streak should never be the reason you buy a company.
This is something I brought up in January as well, when I used 2019 research from David Michayluk, who published a study in the Journal of Applied Corporate Finance. The research was based on a very simple question, which is:
Do companies that keep raising their dividends keep beating the market? And if so, for how long?
They found a few fascinating things:
- After its first dividend increase, a stock usually delivered significant positive abnormal returns (above what one would statistically expect) for the next two years.
- Companies kept positive abnormal returns on earnings after each of their first five annual hikes.
Now pay attention to what happened after that.
- Every additional raise came with lower abnormal returns, and statistics became unreliable.
- After the sixth increase, the abnormal returns were gone.

This means that while a company’s ability to grow the dividend gets rewarded initially, that benefit quickly fades as good news tends to get priced in quickly. And, in this case, quickly refers to the first five years.
So a growth streak of 50-plus years is statistically meaningless for alpha generation. It may be good for peace of mind, as you can somewhat expect a hike every year, but it doesn’t add value to your overall performance. The edge is gone.
What do we make of the combination of both studies I just brought up?
- Dividend growth matters (Hartford)
- The market rewards it most early in the dividend growth story (Michayluk)
This is the reason why I care a great deal more about comeback stories than “dividend royalty.”
What Does A Dividend Growth Streak Tell Us?
Dividend growth data is backward-looking. While a new dividend hike tells us that management is confident in where the company is going, the many hikes before that don’t tell us much about the future.
Why would Realty Income be a better income investment than a younger REIT with a shorter dividend growth history like Agree Realty (ADC)?
Also, companies that have been growing for decades tend to have lost their growth appeal. While that does not apply to all cases, the NOBL ETF, which tracks companies with at least 25 consecutive annual dividend hikes, is massively overweight consumer staples, industrials, financials, and materials, as we can see below.

Just think about 3M (MMM), which ended a 64-year streak. Leggett & Platt (LEG) ended 52 years of consistent hikes. And then there’s Walgreens. These are just three examples.
With that said, many Aristocrats/Kings do better during recessions because they tend to be more conservative. That’s a huge benefit for a retiree or anyone close to retirement.
My point is not to badmouth these companies.
The point I’m making is that you shouldn’t put much emphasis on them.
Three Companies That Built A Lot Of My Wealth
I don’t own Comfort Systems USA (FIX) anymore. Earlier last year, I bought it in the $300 range. I sold it at roughly $1,000 earlier this year (less than a year after I bought it). Given the size of my investment and the short span, it was my biggest realized investment gain ever.
This company is a mechanical and electrical contractor that does HVAC, plumbing, and electrical work for major factories, hospitals, and schools. And because of the data center boom, it added a massive growth engine that explains these returns.

The interesting thing with regard to its dividend is that it has grown its dividend by 35% per year over the past five years, and it still has a low double-digit payout ratio. That’s obviously the result of exploding growth, as revenue in 3Q26 alone rose by 54%.
These numbers are truly wild and benefit the dividend. It’s not the other way around.
I sold because I disliked the valuation and because I knew that once the data center buildout slowed, its margins would likely come down a lot, as pricing power for many companies is built on huge bottlenecks. It will likely keep growing the dividend once that happens due to the low payout ratio, but it wouldn’t be good news for the company.
All I’m saying is that this is a prime example of a great company where the dividend is simply a byproduct, so to speak. On a side note, as FIX now trades below 30x earnings and I’m still bullish on the buildout, I give the stock a Buy rating.
The second pick is GE (GE), which is one of my biggest holdings. I love this company because it essentially dominates three-quarters of the commercial engine market, has a massive defense footprint, and 70% of its revenues come from services.
It sells an expensive engine close to cost and makes money on maintenance and parts for many decades. Innovation is used to stay on top, create better customer relationships, and keep competitors at bay. That’s the business model in a nutshell.
Moreover, it currently yields 0.6% and has a three-year dividend growth CAGR of 94%. In 3Q26, total orders grew by 49%, as this business model is firing on all cylinders.

The interesting thing is that GE is a dividend cutter. That’s why its dividend CAGR in recent years has been so high. Once the GE conglomerate started to weaken, major spin-offs and restructuring processes were needed to create what is now a pure-play aerospace giant.
It completely destroyed the dividend, as you can see below.

While this was annoying (to put it mildly) for long-term investors, new investors got an opportunity to bet on a turnaround. That turnaround worked, and I’m bullish that it will continue. Two decades from now, I think the odds are that GE becomes an Aristocrat again.
The next one is a higher-yielding pick.
Antero Midstream (AM) yields 4.1%. It hasn’t hiked its dividend once since the 2021 cut (see below). That cut was mostly to free up cash for investments in infrastructure.

Buying AM a few years ago got me pushback. And I understand why that is. In the midstream space, people preferred larger players with better dividend track records. However, they underestimated that the real value wasn’t in 5-6% annual dividend growth rates but in how a business is fundamentally changing (it brings me back to the theoretical part of this article).
Antero Midstream spent the past few years aggressively reducing debt, growing along with its customer, Antero Resources (AR), and shaping a strategy that relies on buybacks before dividend hikes.
It has its first investment-grade credit rating (BBB-) from Fitch and now has leverage below its target of 3.0x EBITDA, as you can see below. It’s also growing fast, as gathering volumes in 3Q26 rose by 19%, which helped it to lower debt by more than $400 million in that quarter. And while most of the $400 million came from litigation proceeds, core growth is impressive. That’s why I brought up the 19% number.

This led to accelerated buybacks:
Free cash flow after dividends was $449 million, including $377 million of Clearwater litigation proceeds. This free cash flow was utilized to reduce debt by over $400 million during the quarter and accelerate share repurchases once our leverage target was achieved. – AM 3Q26 Earnings Call
Now, let me explain why this is far from bad. By 2028, analysts expect this company to generate close to $910 million in free cash flow. This is operating cash flow minus capital expenditures. It’s the kind of cash the company can use to pay dividends, buy back stock, and reduce debt. As AM has a market cap of slightly less than $10 billion, it implies a free cash flow yield of slightly more than 9%.
Here’s what that means:
- It has a cash payout ratio of less than 50% based on its current dividend yield. This is the lowest number among all midstream companies on my radar.
- After paying a dividend, it could buy back 4.5% of its market cap every single year (assuming the market cap remains unchanged).
The more stock AM buys back, the better for future dividend growth, as every share that leaves the market won’t get a dividend payment in the future. So, if the business remains strong and free cash flow keeps growing, the company is setting itself up for accelerated future dividend growth. That will likely happen at a point when management believes its equity isn’t cheap anymore.
And for long-term investors, that’s exactly what you want to see.
Hence, despite zero dividend growth since 2021, AM shares have slightly outperformed the midstream and infrastructure ETF (MLPX), as the ratio below shows. Outperformance wasn’t substantial, but the slow uptrend is impressive nonetheless, as AM is such a small regional player that has no direct LNG exposure, no data center deals, no dividend growth, and no major M&A to grow beyond its Appalachia territory.

I feel really good about owning this one and expect it to be in my portfolio for decades.
Three Key Risks
For Comfort Systems, the biggest risk right now is a data center buildout slowdown. The midterm elections triggered these fears. I do not expect it to get worse, but if large hyperscalers were to cut their capex plans, FIX could suffer more.
For GE, the biggest risk is operational. Any major disruptions, including pandemics, widespread wars, and other things, could hurt its growth. Also, a major flaw in an engine program triggering mass maintenance demand would be short-term bearish.
For AM, the biggest risk is a prolonged period of subdued natural gas prices that cause Antero Resources to cut output.
Takeaway
You will never hear me say (or see me write) that dividend streaks are a bad thing. A company that is a Dividend King has earned my respect.
However, and this is a big “however,” respect doesn’t make for a great investment. Data shows that dividend growth streaks quickly lose their added benefit as the market cares more about what’s ahead than what a company has done in the past.
It sounds so obvious, but it’s something many people fall for when they screen stocks for dividend consistency. Don’t do that. Focus on the underlying story.
That’s why none of my biggest winners in recent years were Dividend Aristocrats. Today, I shared three of my best performers, two of which I expect to keep leading my portfolio. We’re talking about a small midstream company that cut its dividend, an aerospace turnaround that also cut its dividend, and a data center proxy that completely relies on data center capex at this point in the cycle.
The dividend is key in all of them for long-term investors, but not the driving factor.
That’s also how I approach investing at Main Street Alpha, as I look at the big picture first. Then, we scan for companies, including what sets them apart. The dividend assessment then follows automatically.






































