Three reasons why markets may be creaking – and three trends to watch
Russ Mould Tuesday, August 6, 2024
A market storm is emerging from a seemingly cloudless summer sky. The question now is whether this is just a tempest in a teapot, and the result of thin trading volumes as the big hitters head to the beach and leave deputies and juniors in charge, or whether it is the harbinger of a more serious – and bearish – shift in market sentiment.
Tracking the yen, the VIX index and the Dow Jones Transportation index might help investors to work out what is coming next, as the worries over the trajectory of the US economy, a rally in the yen and stretched valuations put stock markets to the test.
The NASDAQ is up 110% in the past five years and the S&P 500 by 82%, so investors are now facing the latest test of the old adage that ‘markets go up the escalator and come down in the elevator’. There are many possible reasons for why this squall has seemingly appeared from nowhere.
First, equity (and to some degree bond) markets have priced in the ‘perfect’ scenario of a cooling in inflation, a soft landing in Western economies (and thus corporate earnings) and rate cuts from the Fed, Bank of England and others. Any deviation from that path could therefore lead to trouble – either stickier inflation, economic and earnings disappointment or slower-than-expected rate cuts.
Deviations from that path can be found. Rate cuts have come more slowly than hoped (and the Fed has yet to deliver, after the market started 2024 looking for six, one-quarter point cuts from the US central bank). Inflation has proved stickier and there are signs that the US economy is slowing – unemployment is up, the housing market is a mess and the latest purchasing managers’ index for manufacturing showed weak orders and sticky prices. A US slowdown is not priced in at all – if anything markets were more concerned about it overheating earlier this year – and those with long memories will remember how frantic rate cuts in 2000-02 and 2007-08 failed to stave off a bear market in stocks, because the economy tipped over and corporate earnings fell far faster than the headline cost of money.
Second, the yen is rallying. The Japanese currency has been a major source of global liquidity, as major market players have shorted it, borrowed against it and used that money to go for long risk assets around the globe. The Bank of Japan’s belated efforts to raise rates and defend the yen may be turning off the tap, even if Western central banks are slowly cutting rates to keep liquidity flowing. The yen is rallying, as massive short positions against it are closed out, to drive the currency higher still and force yet more liquidation by the shorts, to create a circle every bit as vicious as it had previously been virtuous.
Source: LSEG Refinitiv data
Finally, US equities in particular have just gone up in a straight line, and done so much faster than GDP growth, or corporate earnings or cash flows. The result is that US equities look expensive. According to FactSet, the S&P 500 trades on 20.6 times forward earnings against a 10-year average of 17.9 and the S&P 500’s market’s capitalisation represents 160% of GDP, an all-time high. On top of that, according to Professor Robert Shiller, the US stock market trades on a cyclically adjusted price/earnings ratio (PE) of 35, a figure only exceeded in 2000 (and that did not end well).
As the old saying goes, valuation never tells you when there may be trouble (or an opportunity), but it will tell investors how far things can go (up or down) before something snaps back the other way. And those numbers suggest either prices must fall some way, or earnings must surge quickly for stock markets to regain their equilibrium – though UK equity prices are nowhere near as stretched as they are in the USA.
Ultimately, valuation will set a high and a floor and they are the best arbiters of prospective returns over the very long term. But to test near-term market sentiment, investors may like to watch three indicators.
The first is the VIX index, the so-called fear index, which measures expectation of US stock market volatility in the month ahead. The long-run average reading since 1994 is 19. It is usually a good counter-cyclical indicator. Sustained periods of low readings, down toward 12 or lower, speak of investor complacency and likely trouble ahead (because it won’t take much to frighten everyone). A sustained run above, say, 30 suggests there is panic around and there may be bargains appearing, but the shake-out in this case could be violent. (This simply distils Buffett’s maxim about being fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful).
Source: LSEG Refinitiv data
The second is again the yen, given its pivotal role in global market liquidity. If the Bank of Japan backtracks on its promise of more rate hikes that might help, although whether that stokes global inflation expectations is another challenge, and rapid cuts from the Fed and other central banks might stoke money supply and liquidity in the West, but they might fuel inflation fears too – which may be why gold is holding firm.
And for those looking for an indicator that looks at both US markets and the US economy (and we are focusing on those are they are the biggest in the world on both counts) then nothing is usually more helpful than the Dow Jones Transportation index. It has lagged the Dow Jones Industrials and lost momentum. That is usually a bad sign, as it speaks of economic weakness. That indicator needs to start trucking again, or a summer squall could turn more serious.
Source: LSEG Refinitiv data
These articles are for information purposes only and are not a personal recommendation or advice.
