11%+ Yields That Are Not Yield Traps

Nov 12, 2026, 7:05 AM ETCSWC, HTGC, BIZD, ARCC, BXSL, ARES, BX, CSWCZ, HCXY

Summary

  • Dividend yields above 11% typically signal significant risks, but occasionally the market offers opportunities to collect exceptionally high income without taking on excessive risk.
  • Strong balance sheets, conservative underlying asset structuring, and proven track records can help protect double-digit dividend payouts.
  • I discuss two compelling income opportunities offering approximately 11% to 12% yields, explain their dividend coverage and risks, and assess why they could deliver attractive long-term total returns.
11 percentage sign isolated on transparent background. 11 percent off 3d. 11% png 3d. 3D rendering.
Vivek Vishwakarma/iStock via Getty Images

Whenever I see a dividend yield north of 10%, yellow flags immediately start to go up, and I instinctively turn to my magnifying glass to take a much closer look to try to find what the catch is. The reason for this is that whenever the market prices a stock at such a high yield, one of at least two things, and quite possibly both, is true:

  • The business stands on extremely risky ground, whether it be its business model, the high risk of disruption or outright implosion, or, at the very least, it’s likely to be on extremely dangerous footing and thereby puts the dividend at risk of an imminent cut or even outright elimination.
  • It is expected to not grow at all and potentially even gradually shrink in size over time.

However, every so often, the market prices dividend yields in the 10%+ range despite the underlying business model being battle-tested and on sound footing, alongside an investment-grade balance sheet with adequate liquidity to support the dividend and the business model for the foreseeable future.

In today’s article, I’m going to detail two such opportunities, namely Capital Southwest (CSWC) and Hercules Capital (HTGC).

Why These 11%+ Yields Have a Major Competitive Advantage

Both of these companies are business development companies (BDCs) (BIZD) that are internally managed, which gives them a significant advantage.

Externally managed BDCs like Ares Capital (ARCC) and Blackstone Secured Lending Fund (BXSL) charge their shareholders management fees and incentive fees that are collected by their management companies, Ares Management (ARES) and Blackstone (BX). These fees scale with the company as well, so even if they issue more shares and grow in size over time, the fees grow right along with them. This leads to minimal economies-of-scale benefits for these funds and materially lower ROEs than their gross ROEs on their investments. Not only that, but sometimes incentives are not perfectly aligned because, at the end of the day, externally managed BDCs exist to generate fees for their managers, whereas internally managed BDCs often just pay salaries to their management teams. Therefore, they scale nicely with declining G&A and operating expenses as they grow in size, and there’s therefore much less incentive to aggressively try to grow the size of those BDCs. Additionally, their fee structures are generally more shareholder-friendly, and therefore they tend to trade at more attractive valuations on a price-to-NAV multiple basis. As a result, BDCs like HTGC and CSWC have historically traded at substantial premiums to their net asset value.

This has several advantages for the company in question because it means they can issue shares at a premium to NAV and thereby grow NAV per share and ultimately NII per share, simply by issuing equity into the market. This benefits existing shareholders and thereby incentivizes them to be long-term shareholders. It also means that their dividends tend to be more sustainable and likely even grow over time because the company can consistently grow NII per share simply by issuing new stock, which further earns trust in the marketplace and makes them even more likely to outperform over time. It also means the companies could grow more rapidly and thereby enjoy economies-of-scale benefits, which further improve their ROIs and profit margins and warrant an even higher valuation multiple.

The one catch here is that these companies need to be able to redeploy the proceeds from capital that they raise from issuing stock into attractive investments that generate good returns relative to the risk they bring on. There is therefore some constraint to this virtuous cycle, but as long as management remains disciplined in their capital allocation, this can be a really powerful tool for generating long-term total return outperformance.

An 11% Yield Backed by a Conservative Loan Portfolio

CSWC primarily lends money to established lower middle-market companies, with typical investments ranging from $5 million to $50 million. They focus primarily on first-lien secured loans and tend to keep their exposure to software loans to a minimum, which serves them well in the current environment where software lending is a bit out of favor. In fact, 99% of its credit portfolio is in first-lien senior-secured loans, and its credit portfolio makes up the vast majority of its overall portfolio value.

The portfolio is performing well right now, with non-accruals at 1.4% on a fair value basis, which is fairly respectable relative to the broader industry. Also, its regulatory debt-to-equity ratio stands at 1.0x, which is pretty reasonable compared to the broader industry, especially given its ability to issue equity at a premium to NAV, which gives it significant further liquidity and an ability to naturally deleverage on an accretive basis if needed.

The company also generated 58 cents of pre-tax net investment income per share, which fully covered its quarterly dividend of 58 cents per share, which it distributes monthly and which annualizes to $2.32 per share. However, it has also been paying a 6-cent-per-share quarterly supplemental dividend, which brings the annualized total payout to $2.56 per share. The company also has undistributed taxable income of about 92 cents per share, which is what is funding its supplemental distribution.

While the dividend coverage is relatively tight right now, CSWC’s modest leverage, conservatively postured portfolio, strong track record, and ability to issue equity at a premium to NAV add further cushion to support the dividend payout. Moreover, its significant undistributed taxable income could also be shifted towards covering the base dividend in the current environment, and it could always abandon the supplemental dividend if needed.

When you combine all that with the fact that CSWC invests primarily in floating-rate loans (and we are in an environment where the Fed is expected to hike rates rather than cut them), as well as the fact that the most recent quarterly results do not fully reflect the impacts of the Federal Reserve’s recent rate hike, CSWC’s base dividend appears to be on sound footing for the foreseeable future. Taking into account that its dividend is yielding about 11%, this makes CSWC an attractive source of income backed by a compounding machine that has delivered significant total return outperformance over the long term.

Chart
Data by YCharts

An 11.7% Yield With a Powerful Growth Engine

The other opportunity I’m going to discuss, namely HTGC, while also an internally managed BDC, focuses instead on the venture debt space. It targets companies that need growth financing without necessarily issuing substantial additional equity; its loans are typically structured to include interest payments as well as upfront fees, prepayment fees, and equity warrants that further enhance the returns HTGC generates from its investments.

Over its years of operation, HTGC has built strong relationships with several venture sponsors that give it recurring opportunities and access to deal flow. That enables it to regularly invest and recycle capital while also being able to raise capital at a premium to NAV in the public markets. It can then recycle that into these investments to generate consistent growth for shareholders.

Its leverage ratio of 0.94x puts it on the low end of its sector’s norm and gives it additional financial flexibility, along with being able to issue equity at a premium to NAV to drive NII per share growth. The company pays out a base dividend of 40 cents per quarter, which was well covered by Q3 NII per share of 47 cents per share, giving it a 1.18x base dividend coverage ratio. It also pays out an 11.7% yield when including the regular dividend payout alongside the annualized supplemental payout.

Combined with significant coverage of its base dividend and full coverage of its supplemental dividend, its 88 cents per share of undistributed earnings, and its strong balance sheet, as well as its track record of delivering attractive total returns over the long term, HTGC looks like a very attractive way to invest in 11%+ yielding equities.

Chart
Data by YCharts

The Biggest Risk Investors Shouldn’t Ignore

That being said, its focus on venture-backed technology and life sciences investments puts it into a bit more speculative territory, as many of these borrowers are not yet consistently profitable and therefore depend on future capital raises to pay off and/or refinance their debt to HTGC. This is especially true if venture funding weakens and IPO markets slow or even shutter.

However, HTGC’s long-term track record of navigating various cycles indicates that its business model is proven and works well over time, which should give investors added comfort. Additionally, HTGC should also benefit from the Fed’s current rate-hiking cycle, as it invests in a lot of floating-rate loans.

Two 11%+ Yields That Could Deliver Much More Than Income

While neither CSWC nor HTGC is among the cheapest BDCs out there and neither invests in the lowest-risk segment of loans in the BDC marketplace, they have proven track records, prudently managed balance sheets and investment portfolios, and currently offer very attractive dividend yields of about 11% to 12%, thereby making them attractive income investments for investors who want to avoid yield traps. As a result, they are high on my watchlist for potential inclusion in my 7% to 8% yielding, total-return-outperforming, and below-market-beta retirement portfolio at High Yield Investor.

This article was written by

52.66K Followers

Samuel Smith